Skip to main content

What I'd Tell the Boy in White

•9 min read
mormonismdeconstructionreligionpersonalreligious-trauma
Every baptism photo I see now sparks a similar question: did that child really have a choice? And what would I say to the boy I was?

Today I saw another post of a child, dressed in white, on their baptism day. The photo was posted by a proud parent. I’ve seen many of these over the years. Each time I’ve seen them since I stopped believing the church is true, it sparks a thought in my head:

Did that child really have a choice?

Over the last several years, I’ve become more familiar with the concept of informed consent and consent in general. I don’t feel like either of these were things that were particularly well explained to me as I was growing up. So now, I find myself wanting to write down some of my thoughts around the practice of baptism and why I now find it difficult to square with the principles of autonomy and informed consent that I hold to now.

What I Don't Remember

I should preface this by saying that I have little memory of my own baptism and the events leading up to it. I don’t remember the conversations with my parents about the choice. I don’t remember the interview with the bishop beforehand. I don’t remember much around being given the gift of the Holy Ghost. Maybe that in and of itself is information. A day that is one of the most monumental in an LDS youth’s life has left little in my own memory. Shouldn't that day have left more of a mark if it was as meaningful as I was raised to think it was?

However, an address by Thomas Monson has lingered in the back of my mind. He talked about his own baptism in his April 2007 conference address, Tabernacle Memories. He recounted a memory of talking to his mother about repentance and the meaning of baptism. He said that he could recall the day of his baptism, “as though it were yesterday.”

I heard this talk before my shift away from faith. Somehow this tidbit stayed in my memory enough for me to want to go back and search for it before writing this. However, my own memories of that supposedly sacred day are so dim as to be all but non-existent. I can’t help but feel at least a little resentful about that as I think about it now.

Perhaps I should allow myself the grace of saying that early childhood memories are elusive for many. I wonder how many church members are able to recall the circumstances around their baptisms with a great amount of specificity. I hope I’m not alone in not remembering much.

President Monson had an almost uncanny ability to recall interactions he had with others during his tenure as a bishop and an apostle. I don’t expect to remember exact conversations verbatim. I would at least expect to remember a feeling. Did I feel like I was doing the right thing? Did being granted the gift of the Holy Ghost make a meaningful difference in my life? Did I feel any different about doing the wrong things than I did before being baptized?

What I'd Tell Him

There are some things I would tell that boy if I could go back and have a conversation with him. I might not be putting these things in the most age-appropriate terms. I don’t have children and my interactions with that age group are limited. So please keep that in mind.

The first thing I would want to tell him is that there is a completely different way to look at the hurtful things we often do to each other as humans. We say cruel or dishonest things. We cause pain physically and emotionally. Sometimes we’re selfish. Sometimes we’re greedy. Sometimes we’re spiteful. We get angry. We get irritated. We get impatient. All of these things are very human. But to categorize them as sin and to internalize the idea that doing these things or feeling a certain way makes someone a horrible person is to give these things far more power than anyone should. Especially when that person is only eight years old.

When you’re eight, you’re still learning so much about how the world works. You’re still learning how to manage emotions that probably still feel too big for your body. Your capacity for long-term planning is still very limited. You’re not allowed to enter legal contracts. You’re not allowed to drink alcohol or smoke cigarettes. You likely are able to ride a bike, but you’re certainly not ready to sit behind the wheel of a car.

Putting the additional burden of the concept of sin and the effects of it on someone that young may not hurt every child that learns it. But if they’re like me, they might come to internalize doing the wrong thing as indicative of who they are and not be able to understand for a long time that you can be a good person that sometimes does hurtful things.

I would tell that young boy that he is not an enemy of any deity because he sometimes makes mistakes. I would tell him that when he hurts someone, it is not a reflection of who he is as long as he takes the steps necessary to repair the hurt. I would tell him that he doesn’t need to repent to someone who wasn’t actually affected by the hurt. There was no need for someone innocent to suffer and die, as Jesus is claimed to, because he did the wrong thing. The way forward is between the people involved. If you hurt someone, you apologize and make every effort to not do it again. I would remind him that humans are very creative in the ways they can come up with to cause hurt, so chances are being able to do this will be something he’ll be doing all his life. Again, not because of any great character flaw or fallen nature, but only because that’s part of being a human that interacts with other humans.

I would tell him that he is allowed to forgive himself once that work is done. We have a sense of empathy for a reason. When we hurt others, we often feel that hurt to some degree or another. That’s why the repair is so important. It’s not just about healing for the other person, it’s about healing himself as well. Reconciliation is about elevating ourselves above the mistake and remembering that relationships are built on the fact that we need each other to thrive.

Choice and Expectation

Now to circle back to the point about consent, I would tell that boy that he has a choice. I know choice is often the word used in those proud parent posts on Facebook. However, when you’re eight, I don’t think you truly understand fully the difference between choice and expectation. You’re still looking for the approval of your parents. You want to do things that make them happy. I don’t remember being explicitly asked whether I wanted to be baptized. I don’t remember being told that I could say no. So that’s what I would want to tell that boy.

Before I do though, I want to acknowledge that every one of the posts I see are from parents who believe they are doing the right thing. I understand that they believe they are leading their children towards a path that will lead to eternal happiness. The expectations being put on each of those children was likely placed on those parents just as much as they were placed on me. I don't question their love. Because of my own experience and the experiences I have heard of so many others, I question whether someone should really be asked to say yes to something as large as what the church asks at such a tender age.

I would tell him that he has the right to say no, not just to the church but to any authority that asks him to do things he is too young to fully understand. I would tell him that he doesn’t yet grasp what the church will expect when it comes to his time, his finances, his energy. And I would tell him to ask the questions I didn’t realize I could ask. He’s allowed to ask what other religious views there are in the world. He’s allowed to know that there are dark things in church history that he might not be able to wrap his head around now. He’s allowed to ask why the church isn’t more transparent about its finances. He’s even allowed to say no to an assessment of his worthiness by a bishop because his worth is not defined by how he answers any series of questions when he’s eight or at any other point in his life.

I want to tell him that carrying the weight of other people’s expectations isn’t something he should feel so responsible to carry. How others perceive him is not his responsibility. I’d want him to know that it’s okay to disappoint people sometimes, perhaps even deliberately. What he wants matters just as much as what anyone else wants. Those that matter will understand when their desires don’t align perfectly.

Whether or Not He Wears the White

The last few things I would want to tell him are that he’s good. He’s good not because of anyone or anything else, but because at his heart he cares about people. He wants other people to be comfortable around him. He doesn’t want to be the creep or the jerk. He isn’t above admitting that he makes mistakes sometimes. His curiosity and his desire to explore are traits that will serve him well through his life.

I would tell him that I’m proud of him no matter where his life takes him. His road isn’t always the easiest. It isn’t the one that was laid out for him. But he’s making the best of it with every effort he can muster.

And I would tell him that I will be proud of him whether or not he wears the white clothes because he’s following his own conscience.